Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Manuel del Rio's avatar

As per The Humpty-Dumpty/Entropy principle, it is easy to break stuff, but not easy to put it back together again.

Expand full comment
Chris Waterguy's avatar

Thank you. I'll always amplify this message.

A friend has been exploring Vedantic practice (a form of Hinduism) for a couple of years. I'll share his perspective – I don't mean it to be authoritative, but I think there's something in it:

1. Vipassana is dangerous, he says, because people take themselves far too seriously and think they matter more than they do. The more you focus on yourself, your desires and wishes and how things should be, the more you suffer.

2. He says re Vipassana's focus on staying with what is arising and letting it go, some people can't let it go and they have a psychotic break.

There are many types of meditation and he's never done that one. (My comment: I think this is probably helpful for the vast majority of people as a 5 or 30 minute meditation, but becomes risky when trying to force it for hours and days.)

3. Meditation is for training the mind to be single-pointed (able to focus), to build resilience and perhaps to heal some trauma. It's not for an experience you get while meditating. "If you want an experience, go on a rollercoaster."

4. If it's not working for you, you shouldn't do it, simple as that.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts